Fixed Gas Detector
A fixed gas detector is wired permanently into a monitored space and reports continuously to a control panel, unlike a portable unit a crew member carries to check a space before entry. It is the difference between an ongoing watch and a single point-in-time reading.
Read more — Fixed Gas Detector explained ▾
What sets fixed detection apart
Portable detectors answer one question at a time: is this space safe to enter right now. Fixed gas detection answers a different question continuously: has anything changed in a space that is normally occupied or normally sealed, such as an engine room, a cargo pump room, a battery locker or, on gas carriers, the cargo compressor room and hold spaces around independent tanks. The sensor heads are hard-wired to a central control panel that logs readings, triggers local and bridge alarms, and in many installations interlocks ventilation fans or shuts down electrical equipment automatically once a set threshold is crossed.
Main components
Sensor heads
Catalytic bead sensors detect flammable gas as a percentage of the lower explosive limit; infrared sensors do the same without consuming the target gas, which makes them tolerant of oxygen-deficient atmospheres; electrochemical cells target specific toxic gases such as H2S or CO; separate cells cover oxygen depletion or enrichment.
Control panel and wiring
The panel powers the sensors, processes the signal, drives audible and visual alarms at two thresholds (typically a pre-alarm and a high alarm), and often provides relay outputs to the fire and safety system. Cable runs into hazardous zones must use intrinsically safe barriers or explosion-proof glands.
Calibration points
Each sensor location has an accessible calibration gas port so the head can be bump-tested and calibrated without removal.
Selection and sizing
Sensor placement is driven by the gas properties and the space geometry: lighter-than-air gases are monitored near deckhead level, heavier vapours near the bilge or tank bottom. The number of points depends on space volume, ventilation pattern and the presence of dead pockets where gas could accumulate undetected. Response time (T90), cross-sensitivity to interfering gases, and the certified explosion-proof rating (commonly IIA, IIB or IIC depending on the gas group) all factor into the choice of sensor type for a given hazardous zone.
Regulations and class requirements
SOLAS Chapter II-2 requires fixed gas detection in specific spaces on tankers, including cargo pump rooms, and class rules extend similar requirements to enclosed spaces where flammable or toxic atmospheres are a known risk. Gas carriers under the IGC Code carry additional fixed detection for cargo hold spaces, interbarrier spaces and compressor rooms, monitoring for both flammable cargo vapour and, where relevant, toxicity or refrigerant leakage. Type approval and periodic testing intervals are set by class and flag administration; records of calibration and function tests are checked at survey.
Typical faults
- Sensor drift over time, giving readings that creep away from true concentration until a routine calibration catches it, or fails to.
- Expired or depleted calibration gas cylinders, leaving the crew unable to verify sensor response when it matters.
- Cable or connector faults in the harsh environment of a pump room or engine room, producing intermittent fault signals or a dead channel.
- Catalytic bead poisoning from silicone vapour or leaded compounds, which silently kills sensitivity while the sensor still appears to respond to bump tests with clean gas.
- Nuisance alarms from condensation or vibration, which crews sometimes respond to by disabling the point rather than fixing the fault, defeating the whole purpose of the installation.
What to look for in a supplier
- Explosion-proof certification appropriate to the zone (IECEx or ATEX, matched to the gas group present).
- Class type approval covering the specific vessel type and application, not a generic industrial certificate.
- Ready availability of matching replacement sensor cartridges, since panels are often kept in service far longer than any individual sensor.
- Calibration kits and bump-test gas suited to the exact sensor range fitted, not a close approximation.
A gas detector that has stopped nuisance-alarming is not necessarily fixed; check whether someone disabled the point before assuming the fault cleared itself.
9 manufacturers · 16 models
Dräger
6
- Sensor poisoning
- 4-20mA signal drift
- Sensor housing corrosion
- Calibration gas port blockage
- Integrated sensor life monitoring reduces unexpected failures
- Self‑diagnostic functions alert to sensor poisoning or signal drift early
- SOLAS‑approved, allowing direct installation in regulated pump rooms and cargo areas
- 4‑20 mA analog output simplifies wiring to existing alarm panels and control systems
- Modular design supports multiple gas sensors (e.g., CO, H₂S, O₂) on a single unit
- Electrochemical sensors require regular calibration (typically every 6 months)
- Sensor housing can corrode in highly humid or salty environments if not maintained
- Analog output only; no native digital (Modbus/Profibus) interface without an external converter
- Initial purchase price higher than basic single‑gas detectors
- Port blockage for calibration gas may occur if maintenance is neglected
- IR source degradation
- Window contamination
- Electronics failure
- Non‑poisoning IR sensor provides long life and low maintenance
- Extended calibration interval (up to 12 months) reduces downtime
- Self‑diagnostic functions alert to source degradation or window fouling
- Robust, explosion‑proof housing suitable for harsh marine environments
- SOLAS approved for mandatory installation on passenger vessels
- Only detects IR‑active hydrocarbons; not suitable for gases like CO or H₂S
- IR source intensity can degrade over time, requiring periodic replacement
- Optical window must be cleaned annually to maintain accuracy
- Higher upfront cost compared with basic electrochemical detectors
- Integration may require specific fieldbus (Profibus/Modbus) infrastructure
Honeywell
3- Source/detector misalignment
- Window fouling
- Electronics aging
- Long detection range (up to several hundred metres) without the need for point sensors along the line
- Self‑diagnosing optics with automatic alignment checks reduces maintenance visits
- Robust marine‑grade housing (IP66/67) suitable for harsh offshore environments
- Low power consumption and ability to integrate via HART, Modbus or 4‑20 mA
- No consumable filters – only periodic window cleaning required
- Detects only IR‑absorbing gases (primarily methane/HC); not suitable for CO, H2S, etc.
- Requires a clear line‑of‑sight; fog, heavy spray or fouled windows can impair performance
- Initial capital cost higher than point‑type catalytic detectors
- Electronics aging and window fouling are known failure modes that need scheduled inspections
- Alignment drift over many years may necessitate recalibration
Crowcon
1
- Sensor end-of-life
- Display failure
- 4-20mA output drift
- OLED display gives immediate local readout of gas level
- Standard 4‑20 mA output allows easy connection to shipboard control and alarm panels
- ATEX/IECEx certified for use in explosive atmospheres, suitable for marine environments
- Compact IP66 housing resists moisture, salt spray and vibration
- Built‑in self‑diagnostics and sensor end‑of‑life warning
- Typically limited to a single gas per detector (requires separate units for multiple gases)
- No native digital protocol (e.g., Modbus) – only analog output is available
- OLED can be hard to read in very bright sunlight or glare
- Sensor must be replaced at end‑of‑life, adding maintenance cost
- Calibration requires external calibrator and periodic manual checks
Det-Tronics
1
- Optical alignment drift
- Window contamination
- Heater failure in cold
- Long detection range suitable for large cargo or machinery spaces
- No moving parts or sampling lines, reducing routine maintenance
- Fast response to gas releases along the optical path
- Can cover multiple compartments with a single sensor line
- Optical alignment can drift over time, requiring periodic re‑alignment
- Window contamination (dust, oil) degrades accuracy and must be cleaned
- Heater element may fail in very cold environments, affecting performance
- Installation requires clear line‑of‑sight; obstructions reduce effectiveness
GfG Instrumentation
1
- Sensor depletion
- 4-20mA signal loss
- Housing seal failure
- Standard 4‑20 mA output integrates easily with existing ship automation and alarm panels
- Modular sensor design allows quick change‑over to different gases (e.g., H₂S, CO, NH₃)
- Robust German‑engineered housing rated for harsh marine environments
- Built‑in self‑diagnostic functions alert to sensor depletion or wiring faults
- Analog‑only output – no native digital protocols (e.g., HART, Modbus) for advanced monitoring
- Sensor life is limited; periodic replacement adds maintenance cost
- Signal loss can occur if wiring or the 4‑20 mA loop is compromised
- Higher initial purchase price compared with basic single‑gas alarms
Honeywell (RAE)
1- PID lamp burnout
- Window contamination
- Electronics drift
- High sensitivity to low‑level VOCs, providing early leak detection
- Fast response time suitable for rapid alarm activation
- Robust housing rated for harsh marine pump‑room conditions
- Lamp replacement is a defined maintenance task with clear intervals
- Integrated audible/visual alarms and optional remote output
- PID lamp has limited life (typically 1–2 years) and must be replaced regularly
- Optical window can become contaminated by dust or oil, requiring periodic cleaning
- Electronics may drift over time, necessitating recalibration
- Not suitable for detecting combustible gases; only VOCs are measured
- Higher power consumption than catalytic sensors
MSA
1
- Sensor drift
- Relay failure
- Display electronics
- Housing seal degradation
- SIL2 rated, providing high safety integrity for critical areas
- HART protocol enables remote diagnostics and parameter tuning
- Standard 4‑20 mA output simplifies integration with ship control systems
- Fixed installation reduces the need for handheld devices in permanent monitoring points
- Robust design suitable for harsh marine environments
- Sensor drift requires regular calibration to maintain accuracy
- Relay and display electronics have documented failure modes
- Housing seal degradation can occur in high‑humidity or salt‑spray conditions
- Limited to fixed locations; not a substitute for portable detectors
- Higher upfront cost compared with basic analog gas alarms
Oldham (3M/Teledyne)
1- Sensor degradation
- Communication fault
- Housing corrosion
- Continuous real‑time monitoring of combustible and toxic gases
- Dual output options (4‑20 mA and Modbus) simplify integration with existing SCADA or alarm panels
- Robust housing designed for marine environments
- Teledyne/3M brand support and proven field reliability
- Straightforward wiring and configuration for fixed installations
- Sensor drift requires scheduled calibration and replacement
- Housing can corrode if not properly maintained in salty atmospheres
- Communication faults (Modbus) may interrupt data transmission
- Only suitable for fixed mounting – no portable capability
- May need a dedicated power supply separate from ship’s main distribution
Simtronics
1- IR optics contamination
- Heater element failure
- Signal drift
- Fast, reliable detection of methane and other hydrocarbons using IR absorption
- Robust housing rated for harsh offshore conditions (water‑tight, corrosion‑resistant)
- Built‑in self‑diagnostics and heater control to minimise drift and false alarms
- Easy integration with Autronica/Simtronics control panels via HART or Modbus
- Low power consumption suitable for remote installations
- Limited to hydrocarbon gases; not suitable for toxic or oxygen‑deficient atmospheres
- Optical window can become contaminated, requiring periodic cleaning
- Heater element failure can cause loss of sensitivity and requires replacement
- Higher upfront cost compared with basic electrochemical sensors
- Requires line‑of‑sight installation to the gas plume